What I liked less was the difficulty of getting the keys for my girlfriend who was to arrive a few hours earlier. Even after I had paid for the hotel in advance (after much back and forth online), she was still asked to provide a card to get the key (she refused). Left a bit of a sour taste. Also, I left a tip for the cleaning staff using an app provided by the hotel (to pay without cash), but they were unsure that it would be directed in the right direction (i.e. to the cleaning staff).

Location, facilities, particularly bar on the rooftop! And, of course the Margaritas. Staff generally friendly..

Stayed in April 2024

loved everything

location, location, location room with big window and lots of light very clean love love the decor

Stayed in May 2024

Shower: little water and water would stop flowing and then restart while one showers. Toiletry is poor. Do not have breakfast at the hotel. Bad quality and bad service.

Room is small but very nice. Good bed, bedding and towels

Stayed in May 2024

We booked this hotel especially for the heated pool. It was a lot more expensive then other accomodation options we found, but we were ok to make the investment so our kids could have a swim after a day in the city. Unfortunately, the pool opening hours were only from 10am till 4pm, which was exactly the time we were exploring the city. These pool opening hours were not clearly communicated during the booking process. We would have chosen a cheaper option would we have known.

Excellent location on Time Square but high enough to not hear anything on the streets. Amazing views from the room.

Stayed in May 2024

Really nice place for a good price right in Times Square. They must have pretty thick windows, because it wasn't noisy at all inside. Small gym downstairs was nice, and the breakfast was a pretty competitive price for the neighborhood. Would definitely stay here again.

Stayed in May 2024

I highly recommend this hotel/resort. It is CLEAN, it is COMFORTABLE. The staff in the whole building were all very nice and accommodating. The food was great! The location is great, walkable to many locations such as Harry Potter, Madame Tussaud's wax museum, the theater district, Bryant Park and the subway stations. The room was clean and the beds were comfortable and we loved it. Worth every penny!

Stayed in April 2024

Thanks for everything if I am coming to lovely city new York I will stay in Margritaville Thank you again

Stayed in May 2024

Room was very small. Barely room for our suitcases but this seems to be the case in most NY Hotels.

Location was excellent. Staff were very friendly and helpful. Room was comfy and spotless clean. Views were great from rooftop bar and our room.

Stayed in May 2024

Shared door between the rooms

Nice staff and perfect located hotel

Stayed in April 2024

Nothing

Everything

Stayed in April 2024

I don't think there should be a wait for customers who are staying at the resort. I was spending the night and was told there was a 20min wait for a table at the main restaurant on the 2nd floor. Even after I hinted if they needed my room number to hold a table. No heaters on the rooftop.

Stayed in April 2024

The snake I saw go into the bush. My biggest fear

Everything I’ll be returning super clean and loads to do I loved it . The staff are amazing so attentive I’m already looking to come back . I can’t give you 10/10 I want to give you 100/100

Stayed in April 2024

A small convenience type store or even vending machine for sodas/snacks after hours would be convenient.

Great location, wonderful amenities on site, fantastic staff

Stayed in April 2024

Rooms are a little bit small but expected since it’s New York

Love the beachy vibes and design. Pool and bars were really cool. Location is amazing.

Stayed in March 2024

Nothing

Location was great , and the twist of the pool was the element of surprise.

Stayed in April 2024

The people hanging around outside on the street. I was happy that there was staff outside and inside the lobby looking out for guests and helping.

I did not have breakfast

Stayed in March 2024

Pricing in bar/restaurants pretty excessive

Gorgeous great amenities

Stayed in April 2024

2nd floor bar area was not clean...very nasty smell from the bar. Breakfast was expensive and not good.

Location was awesome. Rooms were small but wonderfully laid out and equipped with coffee machine and refrigerator.

Stayed in April 2024

Need renovation for the elevators.

Close to time squares, restaurants and bars.

Stayed in April 2024

The service at the Landshark restaurant was slow, and it was difficult how to use the elevators the first time.

I liked the fact that it was close to the subway and that even in the busy area, it was quiet. The staff was awesome, and the room was cute. I also liked that we did have to go outside and eat that the restaurant was there. I also liked when the staff was understanding to a situation beyond my control that made me 15 minutes late to check out. That shows that they care about their guests. I will definitely come here again.

Stayed in April 2024

Very creative and interesting

I really love the spot and it was very creative and it was very interesting

Stayed in April 2024

Nothing

Clean and location is great

Stayed in April 2024

Food in the restaurants was rarely vegetarian …

Pool was nice. Great connection to public transport

Stayed in April 2024

- Validate parking, it was not as much as we thought. - No breakfast included, as stated in the reservation.

Cleanliness and decor, also the location is excellent.

Stayed in April 2024